Life, Complexity, Emergence and how it all relates

 

This is an interesting story about things we take for granted, that have a meaning and origin that will surprise. Many years ago, due to the work we did in the design of complex systems, we started trying to understand complexity and how it comes about. The first question was what defines complexity? Basically, anything designed by humans that involves feedback, can be considered complex; involve a human as an operator and the complexity grows very quickly. The art of designing complex systems is to produce a desired emergent behaviour; for example, stable flight in an aircraft; there can also be undesirable emergent behaviours that are destructive, for example oscillations produced by wind in a bridge that resonate and destroy the bridge.

The bit missing is that to understand complexity and producing better systems is a multi-disciplinary activity. Until only a decade ago multi-disciplinary teams were a rarity. My own experiences reflect this. Look anywhere in the world over the last few decades at the number of spectacular project failures; at the heart of these failures has been a lack of understanding of complexity and the emergence of destructive failure modes. Examples include, Space Shuttle and the Snowy Mountain scheme. The first leading to many deaths and the second leading to enormous blow outs in cost and schedule. Both were avoidable.

Let’s now move to biological systems, these involve feedback, emergence and are therefore complex, very complex. A brief pause here as emergence deserves a bit more attention. In engineering when we are designing complex systems getting the desired emergent behaviour is quite difficult, and in some respects, even mystical; just think about it you put a rider together with a bicycle and you get a moving controlled platform; a biological equivalent would be consciousness in the brain which is about as complex as it gets; nature has had the benefit of billions of years of experiments. In engineering we model and simulate and use safety cases to ensure we avoid unwanted failure modes. In engineering and science, the word emergence is not commonly used, however the biologist, have been using it for a very long time.

The twentieth century was the era of Physics and the twenty first century will be the era of Biology. However, biology lacks many of the tools of physics and is in its infancy as a science. Fortunately, some smart people in New Mexico created the Santa Fe Institute, which brings multidisciplinary teams together to look at complex problems, so biological systems have been receiving a lot more attention.

One area of research relates to the life of mammals, we human beings included. One of the characteristics that came out of research was the presence of power law scaling in complex systems. In fact, if you find power law relationships you realise you are dealing with complexity. We can start with the smallest mammal and using power law scaling determine the heart rate and other key parameters of the largest mammal. An additional outcome is that all mammals have on average 1.5 billion heart beats in their lifetime. Due to the higher hearts rates of the smaller mammals, they live considerably shorter lives than the larger mammals. Human followed this trend until about 100 years ago, when due to technology and better health practices the infant mortality rate reduced dramatically; the result over this hundred-year period was a doubling of our life span; we now have on average 2.5 billion heart beats in a typical lifespan. Humans are the only species to do this.

Some interesting outcomes from complexity research:

  • Why do we age? Well, it has been found that given we have a certain input of energy that powers our ATP process in our mitochondria; some of this energy goes towards growth, especially when we are young and the rest towards maintenance to keep everything healthy and working. As we get older more energy goes towards maintenance, until there is none left for growth. At this point we stop growing and start ageing. Surprisingly this occurs at quite a young age, around the twenties.
  • In large scale complex projects, the development team itself becomes a complex entity. Given this situation it is not surprising they experience cost and schedule overruns. It is quite difficult to convince a Program Manager of the need to do expensive modelling and simulation to avoid pitfalls and get the design right.
  • Artificial Intelligence: this is a key area of complexity, and recent reports of the AI breaking into systems with unintended consequences is not surprising. Emergence of unintended behaviours is part and parcel of the design of complex systems.
  • Climate change is a very controversial and political area, which unfortunately has been poorly managed. The whole process epitomizes complexity, for example our inability to make accurate predictions should not be a surprise. We as a race are growing exponentially in population, with ever increasing energy requirements, and need to appreciate what the potential sources of energy are; each has its pros and cons as well as time viable frames. A simple example is rooftop solar, taking advantage of the Suns energy, which is literally unlimited. Battery back-up can make a domestic installation stand-alone, additionally, providing free fossil fuel energy for an electric car. When you look at this financially, initially the business case does not seem to stand up, however, this is very short sighted. We now have utilities buying back power to supplement the grid; we now have homes being independent of unreliable power sources, and independent of widely fluctuating fossil fuel prices. If you remove the politics and educate the masses, it is quite obvious what the solution is.
  • A final example is in health, and in particular the treatment of cancer. Unfortunately, women seem to fall victim to cancer disproportionately. The history of cancer goes back as far as humanity itself. The treatment regime of cancer in the last decade is based on the recognition of cancer as a complex system, requiring multi-parameter treatments. Complexity has also led to a better understanding of how tumours, grow and possible future treatments.

I could go on further and may look at a second instalment, down track. The area of complexity is fascinating and highly relevant to our future, globally as a race. The work of the Santa Fe Institute is very relevant. This article has been inspired by the work of Geoffrey West in his book Scale, as well as the work of many of his colleagues. An earlier book, Conceptional Foundations of Multi-Disciplinary Thinking, by Stephen Kline, also made me take attention more closely at this area, and apply the concepts to areas we were working in. In particular, top down and bottom-up approaches to system design.

Leave a Reply