How to Choose a Surrogate (And What to Look For Beyond the Profile)
Finding the right surrogate is more than ticking boxes on a checklist — it’s about trust, alignment, and intuition. Whether you’re a hopeful parent navigating infertility, a same-sex couple starting your family, or choosing surrogacy after a medical complication, one of the biggest decisions you’ll ever make is who will carry your baby.
And while agencies offer medical reports, background checks, and polished profiles, the truth is — the real connection is emotional and personal.
Here’s how to choose a surrogate with confidence — not just based on charts, but on values, communication, and the kind of partnership that makes this sacred journey possible.
First, Understand the Role of a Surrogate
There are two main types of surrogates:
1. Gestational Surrogate (Most Common)
• No biological connection to the baby
• An embryo is created via IVF using donor or intended parent(s)’ sperm and egg
• The surrogate is the carrier only, not the genetic mother
2. Traditional Surrogate (Less Common)
• Uses her own egg, making her biologically related to the child
• Typically achieved through artificial insemination (not IVF)
• Legal and emotional complexities are higher
Most agencies and intended parents choose gestational surrogacy for clarity and legal security.
Where Do You Find a Surrogate?
You can choose to:
• Work with a surrogacy agency — they match you with vetted candidates
• Go independent — you find a surrogate through your network or online
• Ask a friend or family member (called altruistic surrogacy in some countries)
Agencies often offer added legal, medical, and logistical support — but always verify reputation, costs, and inclusivity.
What to Look for in a Surrogate (Beyond the Basics)
The profile might list age, BMI, previous pregnancies, and medical history — and yes, those are important. But here’s what really matters when choosing your surrogate:
1. Communication Style
• Do you want regular updates? Monthly check-ins? Casual texts?
• Does she feel open, respectful, and emotionally attuned?
• Can you navigate tough conversations together?
This journey requires honest, ongoing communication — choose someone you feel safe talking to.
2. Shared Values
• What are her views on selective reduction or termination (if medically necessary)?
• Does she share similar beliefs about birth preferences or medical interventions?
• How does she feel about open vs closed relationships post-birth?
Alignment now avoids emotional conflict later.
3. Emotional Stability
Pregnancy is intense — physically and emotionally. Surrogates should:
• Be in a stable life situation
• Have strong support networks
• Feel confident in their motivation to carry for someone else
Most reputable agencies perform psychological evaluations — but trust your gut, too.
4. Motivation for Becoming a Surrogate
The best surrogates often say:
“I loved being pregnant — and I want to help someone else become a parent.”
That motivation is gold. Ask her why she chose surrogacy — and listen beyond the words.
5. Experience with Pregnancy
Ideally, your surrogate has:
• Carried at least one child to term
• Had low-risk pregnancies
• Fully recovered emotionally and physically
Some surrogates are doing this for the second or third time — which can be a huge plus.
6. Boundaries & Independence
A strong surrogate will:
• Respect your role as the parent(s)
• Follow medical guidelines
• Maintain her personal autonomy
• Set healthy boundaries with love
You want a partner — not someone looking to be “rescued” or controlled.
Questions to Ask During the Surrogate Interview
Whether via Zoom or in-person, come prepared. Try:
• “How did you decide to become a surrogate?”
• “What are your expectations during the pregnancy?”
• “How do you feel about intended parent involvement?”
• “What support system do you have in place?”
• “How would you like our relationship to feel?”
• “What’s your birth philosophy or experience been like before?”
And most importantly: Can we do this together with mutual respect and heart?
Red Flags to Watch For
• Pressured timelines or rushing into the match
• Discomfort discussing hard topics (termination, health decisions)
• Lack of support at home
• History of complications not disclosed upfront
• Financial desperation as a primary motivator
Pause, reflect, and consult your surrogacy team if anything feels off.
Your Rights (and Hers) Matter
You have the right to:
• Choose who carries your child
• Ask questions and set clear expectations
• Receive medical updates and be present for the birth (when permitted)
She has the right to:
• Be treated with dignity and autonomy
• Make decisions about her own body
• Receive compensation and medical care as outlined in your agreement
This is a shared journey — not a transaction.
Legal Considerations
Before moving forward:
• Hire a lawyer who specializes in reproductive law
• Draft a detailed surrogacy agreement
• Discuss rights to the baby, medical consent, and future contact
• Follow local laws — surrogacy legality varies by country and state
Even with the best connection, protect everyone with strong legal groundwork.
Final Thoughts
Choosing a surrogate is a heart decision wrapped in legal, medical, and emotional layers. Go slow. Trust your intuition. And know that the right match will feel less like a transaction and more like a team.
You’re not just choosing someone to carry your baby — you’re inviting someone into one of the most intimate and transformational chapters of your life.
Choose connection. Choose trust. Choose love.
Google